| The
Editors |
Dan
Stradford, Editor
Alan Graham, Assistant Editor
Gloria McTaggart, Assistant Editor
SafeHarborProj@aol.com
www.AlternativeMentalHealth.com
Feedback: We'd like
to hear your comments and views. Please forward them
to the e-mail address above. Contact information is
below.
|
| Subscriptions |
Did
someone forward this ezine to you? You can subscribe
for yourself by visiting our web site and using the
sign-up form there, or just by sending a blank
e-mail to...
amh.10@add.postmastergeneral.com
Complete unsubscribing instructions are at the
end of this message. Or, you can reply to this
message and ask to be removed from the list.
|
| About
Safe Harbor |
| Safe
Harbor was founded in 1998 in the wake of growing
public dissatisfaction with the unwanted effects of
orthodox psychiatric treatments such as medication
and shock therapy. Seeking to satisfy the desire for
safer, more effective treatments, Safe Harbor is
dedicated to educating the public, the medical
profession, and government officials on research and
treatments that, minimally, do no harm and,
optimally, cure the causes of severe mental
symptoms. Our primary thrust is education on the
medical causes of severe mental symptoms and the use
of nutritional and other natural treatments.
|
| WE
WELCOME YOUR DONATIONS. AS A NONPROFIT
ORGANIZATION, SAFE HARBOR IS SUPPORTED SOLELY
THROUGH THE GENEROSITY OF THE PUBLIC. DONATIONS
CAN BE MADE ONLINE AT OUR WEB SITE OR MAILED TO
THE ABOVE ADDRESS. WE ALSO ACCEPT VISA/MASTERCARD
BY PHONE. THANK YOU. |
|
| EDITOR'S
COMMENT |
|
In mid-June of this year, Safe Harbor will be
presenting in the Los Angeles area an outstanding
2-day seminar on "Natural Treatment of Mental
Disorders." We will announce the exact time and
location in our next ezine.
The seminar is designed for healthcare
professionals, including physicians, chiropractors,
nutritionists, nurses and others in the medical
field. Non-medical public are welcome.
Featured speakers will include, among others,
holistic psychiatrist and author Dr. Hyla Cass and
Professor James Croxton, who teaches one of the very
few collegiate level courses on nutrition and mental
health in the United States.
The seminar will cover such topics as nutrients
and nerve function and the roles of allergies,
toxins, metabolic problems and medical ailments in
causing severe mental symptoms labeled as
schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, depression,
anxiety, etc.,
Professional education on natural treatments of
mental disorders is virtually non-existent in the
United States and Safe Harbor takes great pride in
bringing this much-needed knowledge to healthcare
professionals in the first of many such seminars we
hope to deliver.
|
| SAFE
HARBOR LAUNCHES ANNUAL MEMBERSHIP DRIVE |
|
Safe Harbor is launching its annual membership
drive!
We are moving into our fourth year and going
strong, changing lives every day. Every week
thousands come to our Web site for help and
information. We are currently working on programs
with Los Angeles County and the State of California,
including educating doctors on non-drug
alternatives. We continue to give well-received
workshops to the public on non-drug alternatives. We
have received support from the prestigious
California Endowment, the Bank of America
Foundation, Wells Fargo Foundation, and the Norman
Lear Foundation.
Thanks to Safe Harbor's work, the field of
alternative mental health is growing rapidly and
gaining favor and understanding in the public
consciousness. Our continued success depends a great
deal on the donations of people like yourself, who
want to see the field of mental health and the lives
of those involved improved. By partnering with us
through your membership fees, you help us deliver:
- 24 Hour Access to
www.AlternativeMentalHealth.com
- "ADD" Educational Workshops for
Parents, Teachers, Social Workers & the
Public
- Alternative Mental Health Workshops
- Alternative Mental Health Workshops
- Online Physician & Practitioner Referral
List
- Direct Phone and E-mail Consultation
- Community Mental Health Reform
- Practitioner Training and More!
Please print out and provide the information
requested below and mail to:
Safe Harbor
1718 Colorado Boulevard
Los Angeles, CA 90041
U.S.A.
You may also go to www.AlternativeMentalHealth.com
and make your donation online, or call 818-890-1862
and we will take your information by phone.
Membership:
- $1-44 Free Monthly Ezine (online newsletter)
- $45 Free Monthly Ezine & Bumper Sticker
- $75 Free Monthly Ezine, Bumper Sticker &
T-shirt (Circle size: M L XL)
- $125 Free Monthly Ezine, Bumper Sticker,
T-shirt (Circle size: M L XL) & your choice
of Book: _____ No More ADHD OR _____
Orthomolecular Treatment of Schizophrenia
- $200+ Get all of the above and a special gift
I would like to donate [ ] I would like to volunteer [ ]
Name ___________________________________________________________
Address ________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
Telephone ___________________ E-mail ________________________
Thank you very much for helping us continue
changing lives every day!
|
| "A
BEAUTIFUL MIND" DISHONEST ABOUT ROLE OF
ANTIPSYCHOTICS |
|
In biographical
filmmaking, it is accepted practice to invent minor
incidents or characters to help move the story
along, add color, or inject a bit of drama. "A
Beautiful Mind," however, takes fictionalizing
to a new level.
The Oscar-nominated
film purports to document the life of the brilliant
mathematician John Nash who overcame a problem
diagnosed as schizophrenia and went on to win a
Nobel Prize. The movie claims Nash recovered
thanks to modern medications. The statement is
completely false.
Public reaction has
been swift.
In Newsweek (March
11, 2002), Nash biographer Sylvia Nasar set the
record straight:
"Moviegoers
will be surprised to learn that powerful new drugs
like clozapine played no role in Nash's recovery.
Another kind of chemistry apparently did, however.
Like fewer than one in 10 individuals who suffer
from chronic schizophrenia, Nash 'emerged from
irrational thinking ultimately without medicine
other than the natural hormonal changes of aging,'
as he later put it. No one knows why a lucky
minority experience a dramatic lessening of symptoms
in late middle age."
Factually, studies
show the drug-free recovery rate for schizophrenia
to be far higher than 10%. This is so well
known that Manfred Beuler - the son of the
psychiatrist who invented the term
"schizophrenia" - reported that 53% to 68%
of schizophrenics he studied (an average of 23 years
after onset) recovered completely or improved
significantly.
Support Coalition
International, a collection of 100 mental health
advocacy groups, issued a public statement on March
6 asking Universal Studios, Imagine, and DreamWorks
Pictures for an apology and clarification, stating
in part:
"Apparently
bowing to political correctness, the filmmakers
instead had Nash claim he was taking 'newer
medications' at the time he received his Nobel
Prize. John Nash and his biographer have confirmed
this statement is fictitious. Nash was drug free.
"This film is
helping millions admire the resilience of
psychiatric survivors. But this film also seriously
misleads the public. The fact is, many people --
like Nash -- recover without taking psychiatric
drugs. By caving in to pressure, the film has become
an advertisement for the psychiatric drug industry.
Nash himself wonders if the fact that one of the
film's writers is related to a psychiatric
professional played a role in this distortion."
A March 4, 2002, USA
Today commentary by author Robert Whitaker (March 4,
2002) points out:
"...the World
Health Organization (WHO) has repeatedly found that
long-term schizophrenia outcomes are much worse in
the USA and other 'developed' countries than in poor
ones such as India and Nigeria, where relatively few
patients are on anti-psychotic medications. In
'undeveloped' countries, nearly two-thirds of
schizophrenia patients are doing fairly well five
years after initial diagnosis; about 40% have
basically recovered. But in the USA and other
developed countries, most patients become
chronically ill. The outcome differences are so
marked that WHO concluded that living in a developed
country is a 'strong predictor' that a patient never
will fully recover."
Boston University's
Courtenay Harding, Ph.D., one of the world's leading
experts on schizophrenia recovery, responded in the
March 10, 2002, New York Times. She spoke of a
study she and her colleagues did in Vermont that was
reported in the June 1987 American Journal of
Psychiatry. "When the patients... were
contacted for a University of Vermont study, 62
percent to 68 percent were found to be significantly
improved from their
original condition or to have completely recovered.
The most amazing finding was that 45 percent of all
those... no
longer had signs or symptoms of any mental illness
three decades later."
Harding told
Alternative Mental Health News, "What made this
study more amazing was that these people were the
worst of the worst to start out with. They
were from the back wards."
In Hegarty et al's
(American Journal of Psychiatry 1994)
"meta-analysis of 320 outcome studies covering
all countries, all decades, with 51,800 subjects 5-6
years after being diagnosed schizophrenic with broad
criteria," 46.5% improved. Wiersma's (1998)
15-year follow-up of a Dutch cohort found 27% with
complete remission, 50% with partial
remission."
Many of the
ex-patients in the studies listed above were
evaluated 20 to 35 years after discharge. Those who
recovered include ex-patients once viewed as the
most profoundly disturbed.
So far, the makers
of "A Beautiful Mind" have made no comment
explaining the false statement about Nash's
recovery.
|
| U.K.
FOOD AND MOOD CONFERENCE SCHEDULED |
|
A groundbreaking food and mood conference is
scheduled to take place in London on September 18,
2002. Presented by Pavilion Publishing in
association with the Food and Mood Project, it aims
to consider the application of nutritional and
dietary approaches for improving mental and
emotional health in adults.
This national conference will bring together a
broad range of expertise and experience to provide a
unique opportunity to explore this emerging
complementary approach to mental health care.
Researchers and clinicians will report on their
findings together with service users and support
group leaders who are experts in the self-help
approach. The day will offer a valuable learning and
networking opportunity for statutory and voluntary
sector professionals responsible for the mental
health and social care of adults, as well as service
users and interested members of the public.
The program, which includes refreshments and
lunch, also gives delegates the opportunity to
gather in smaller working groups for seminars on a
range of nutritional topics, led by top
nutritionists working in the field. The seminars
include nutritional approaches to:
- Anxiety and Depression
- Behavior and Criminality
- Cravings and Addictions
- Mood swings and PMS
- Schizophrenia
Speakers include:
Richard Brook, Mind (a British nonprofit)
Alison Faulkner, Mental Health Foundation
Amanda Geary, The Food and Mood Project
Patrick Holford, The Institute for Optimum Nutrition
Paul Shattock, Autism Research Unit, University of
Sunderland
Jan Wallcraft, Sainsbury Centre for Mental Health
For further details please contact Pavilion
Publishing on 01273 623222 or visit www.pavpub.com.
|
| UNITED
NATIONS CLAIMS PRESCRIPTION DRUGS OVERUSED |
|
International experts say developed countries are
using too many prescription drugs. The UN
International Narcotics Control Board (INCB) issued
the warning in its 2000 report.
The Vienna-based board of international experts
oversees the implementation of UN drug treaties, and
how countries are complying.
The report criticized the widespread use of
mood-altering drugs for social problems, such as
unemployment or relationship difficulties. A survey
by the INCB found that even patients who were not
diagnosed as mentally ill were frequently prescribed
mood-altering stimulants.
Benzodiazepines (tranquilizers) are a major
problem. In the US, the forms of benzodiazepine used
to treat anxiety and obesity disorders are used 10
times as often as in Europe. In Europe, the forms of
drug used as a sedative are used three times as
often as in the US. Statistics were given to
highlight the role of aggressive marketing
practices, loose prescription regulations, and
unethical prescribing.
INCB president Professor Hamid Ghodse said an
oversupply of drugs can be as big a problem as the
under-supply of pain-relieving drugs to developing
countries, which the previous year's report
emphasized.
"Up to 70% of long-term use of psychotropic
drugs is irrelevant and often prescribed for social
reasons."
He said although an estimated 30% of the
populations of developed countries were obese, the
use of anti-obesity drugs was due to fashion.
"People are too focused on making their shape
into what is perceived as attractive."
Policing drugs trading on the internet is a high
priority, said the board, which is urging
governments to set up regulatory controls for online
pharmacies. Thailand-based online pharmacies were a
source of illegal drugs for addicts in the US until
combined efforts of the two countries shut down the
unethical sites.
|
| SELECTIVE
ANTIDEPRESSANT TRIALS CHALLENGED |
|
A recent study by Brown University, published in
the American Journal of Psychiatry March 2002, found
that as few as 15 percent of patients evaluated in
the Rhode Island Hospital Department of Psychiatry
outpatient clinic would have met the eligibility
requirements of a standard drug trial.
The researchers reviewed the inclusion and
exclusion criteria used in 31 antidepressant trials
published from 1994 to 1998 in five leading
psychiatric journals. Exclusions consisted of
patients with psychotic features, a history of manic
episodes, suicide risk, unstable medical illnesses,
or a history of drug or alcohol abuse. Several also
excluded subjects with eating disorders,
obsessive-compulsive disorder or panic disorder.
Nearly all of the studies excluded patients who fell
below a cutoff score on a measure of symptom
severity, even though they were diagnosed with major
depression.
"Drug companies are concerned that
individuals with mild depression will respond just
as well to a placebo as they will to antidepressant
medication," said Mark Zimmerman, associate
professor of psychiatry and human behavior, director
of outpatient psychiatry at Rhode Island Hospital,
and lead researcher in the study. "However,
this represents a sizable number of individuals who
are prescribed these medicines, especially by
primary care physicians."
The researchers conducted diagnostic evaluations
of 346 patients ranging in age from 16 to 65 at the
Rhode Island Hospital Department of Psychiatry
outpatient practice. They found that two-thirds of
the patients had the common exclusion criteria, and
patients with anxiety raised this to 85 percent -
yet more than 90 percent of the patients in the
study for whom prescribing information was available
were being treated with antidepressants at the time
of the evaluation.
"When you take any medicine you assume it's
been found to be effective for your condition,"
said Zimmerman. "No one knows for sure whether
antidepressants are effective for most of the
patients we treat."
Some extrapolation of antidepressant studies by
clinicians will always be necessary, Zimmerman said.
It would be impossible to establish the
effectiveness of antidepressant medications in every
conceivable population of depressed patients. But
the current practice of limiting studies to only
"pure" moderate-to-severely ill
depressives may skew the findings of drug trials, he
added.
Opening antidepressant trials to patients with a
wider range of symptoms would allow researchers to
learn whether any specific subsets respond or do not
respond to a drug. The question now is whether
government mandates are necessary to make trials
more inclusive, Zimmerman said. There is little
motivation for drug companies - whose primary aim is
to show that their medication is safe and that it
works for some patients - to do this.
"Drug companies have been correct in
assuming that if they show their medicine works for
a highly select group of depressed patients,
physicians will use it for all patients," said
Zimmerman.
If antidepressants are, in fact, not effective
for some of these large subgroups of depressed
individuals, their prescription incurs an
unjustifiable exposure of risks and side effects,
and alternative treatments need to be considered.
|
| ALTERNATIVES
TO SEDATIVES SOUGHT FOR UK DEMENTIA PATIENTS |
|
Britain's Alzheimer's Society has received
funding for a major research project to search for
alternatives to antipsychotic and sedative drugs for
dementia patients.
The Alzheimer's Society is concerned that
neuroleptic drugs are being used inappropriately and
over-prescribed to people with dementia. In a
statement, the society said that neuroleptics are
often used to 'control' behavior that people may
find difficult to deal with, including aggressive
behavior or 'wandering,' rather than attempting to
understand or investigate the cause, e.g. distress,
feelings of humiliation or fear.
"Once prescription of one of these drugs has
been initiated, although this may be reviewed,
doctors and care staff are often reluctant to
consider stopping the medication in case this
results in a worsening of behavior. As a result,
patients were often prescribed drugs for months or
years even though there was little evidence of
long-term benefit, even if the drugs had a positive
effect in the short term.
"For most patients the drugs cause severe
and unpleasant side effects including excessive
sedation, increased confusion, muscle rigidity,
tremors and falls. Some research has also suggested
that neuroleptic drugs reduce the life expectance of
people with dementia."
The four-year research project will be centered
in three locations in England, and will test the
efficacy and acceptability of alternatives to
regular psychotropic prescription for those people
with dementia who present the most serious
behavioral problems.
|
| ONE
IN 10 NORTH CAROLINA BOYS DRUGGED FOR ADHD SYMPTOMS |
|
A recent report by scientists from the National
Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (a
component of the U.S. Natl. Institute of Health),
has raised some eyebrows regarding the rise in
children diagnosed with "ADHD."
Their recent study of over 6,000 parents in a
"typical" county in North Carolina found
that more than 15 percent of boys in grades one
through five have been diagnosed with ADHD, and
two-thirds of those diagnosed were taking Ritalin or
comparable medication for the condition.
"Treatment rates are usually viewed as
abnormally high if they exceed the three to five
percent prevalence estimate for ADHD cited in an
American Psychiatric Association manual in
1994," the authors said.
The report means that in this typical county one
out of every ten school boys is being drugged for a
condition which many in the medical field don't even
believe exists. In fact, Dr. Xavier
Castellanos of the National Institute of Mental
Health, considered the nation's leading expert on
ADHD, stated in a Frontline interview in 2001 that
he did not even know what ADHD is.
As stated by Jonathan Leo, Ph.D., in the Jan/Feb
issue of Social Science and Modern Society in his
article "American Preschoolers on
Ritalin," "The ADHD experts are quick to
point out that ADHD is one of the most thoroughly
investigated and well-studied pediatric diseases. It
is certainly true that millions of dollars,
countless hours, and tremendous resources have all
been consumed in an enormous effort to investigate
ADHD. Yet, fundamental questions about ADHD are
still vigorously debated. There is no proof of any
underlying neurobiological deficit, it is not clear
what the proper treatment should be, and it is not
clear that the label 'ADHD' is even valid. Even the
American Psychiatric Press Textbook of Psychiatry,
which overwhelmingly supports the idea that ADHD is
a biological disease, has statements such as, 'With
unclear diagnostic boundaries, it is difficult to
define or even conceptualize a unitary concept of
ADHD or its etiology (p. 838),' or 'there remains
considerable uncertainty about the validity of ADHD
as a diagnostic entity (p. 827).'"
The North Carolina study recommends that further
investigation be done to determine if there would be
similar results in other counties.
Dr. Leo's article focuses on the underlying
promotional activity that he feels is being passed
off as science by the promoters of Ritalin, and the
fact that even three-year-olds are being forced to
ingest a stimulant drug that may alter their
developing brain without any evidence that it is for
their benefit.
Dr. Leo's response to further research?
"Handing out more money to investigate the
safety of Ritalin ... is exactly the kind of
thinking that has created the current mess, and more
money will only make more of a mess."
|
| ABOUT
AlternativeMentalHealth.com |
|
ALTERNATIVEMENTALHEALTH.COM IS THE WORLD'S
LARGEST WEB SITE DEVOTED exclusively to alternative
mental health treatments. It includes a directory of
over 200 physicians, nutritionists, experts,
organizations, and facilities around the U.S. that
offer or promote safe, alternative treatments for
severe mental symptoms. Many of the physicians
listed do in-depth examinations to find the physical
causes behind mental problems.
Also included on the site is an array of articles
on topics ranging from the medical causes of
schizophrenia to the effects of toxic metals on
mental health.
Special AlternativeMentalHealth.com T-shirts and
bumper stickers are available at our online store,
as well as a Montel Williams video on alternative
treatment for children labeled with ADD.
A bookstore page lists top books that cover many
areas of alternative treatments with titles like
Natural Healing for Schizophrenia and Other Common
Mental Disorders and No More Ritalin.
AlternativeMentalHealth.com has been created to
educate the public, practitioners, and government
officials on the medical conditions that create
"mental illness" and the many safe
resources available for addressing and often curing
severe mental symptoms.
|
|